Friday, November 21, 2014

Has Strength And Conditioning Been Detrimental To The Game Of Rugby?

Over the past century strength and conditioning has become more and more predominant in contact sports and athletes have significantly grown in terms of muscle hypertrophy.  In the professional game of rugby today, the average player is 6 foot 2 inches in height and 16 stone, 5 pounds in weight. (Peters, S. 2014)
Strength training brings a number of benefits to rugby players, such as:

- Prevention of injury through the strengthening of muscles, ligaments and tendons surrounding the joints.

- Increase in muscle hypertrophy resulting in an increase in strength, producing a more explosive, powerful athlete.

(Official Site of the RFU, Governing Body of Rugby Union in England.)

Since 1974, the average back line rugby player has increased in height by 3 inches and by 31 pounds in weight. As players have increased in size, the number of injuries that occur has also drastically increased. In 1974, there was approximately an injury every 3.4 matches. Forty years on, an injury occurs every 59 minutes on average. 
(Garraway, W M., Lee, A J., Hutton, S., Russell, E B A W., Macleod, D A D. (2000).

So do the benefits strength training brings to the game outweigh its detrimental effect that sees injury rates increasing across all levels of play? Some would argue yes commenting that it has enhanced the level of intensity the game is played at.

Despite the risks associated with weight training, top-level teams have various experts at hand who run injury prevention clinics with the players. What has to be remembered is that rugby is a contact sport and injuries will always occur. Strength training has produced more powerful, all round athletes. Some consider that this has benefited the sport with rugby becoming faster and every player (even twenty stone men) required to be in peak condition to meet the demands of the physical game.  For the spectator they would argue, the game is now more enjoyable to watch.


References

Garraway, W M., Lee, A J., Hutton, S., Russell, E B A W., Macleod, D A D. (2000). Impact of Professionalism on Injuries in Rugby Union. Abstract from the paper. (http://bjsm.bmj.com/content/34/5/348.abstract



Official Site of the RFU, Governing Body of Rugby Union in England. What is Strength Training? (http://www.rfu.com/takingpart/fitness/fitnessattributes/strength)



Peters, S (2014). Rugby’s obsession with strength and power is forcing the game to the brink of crisis. Mail Online.  (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/rugbyunion/article-2571061/Rugbys-obsession-size-power-forcing-game-brink-crisis-concussion-campaign.html)